Monday, December 21, 2009

The Princess and the Frog, The Limits of Control

The Limits of Control (Jim Jarmusch, 2009) D+

Redundant to the point of being hypothetical. Jarmusch's comment on the state of cinema isn't unwelcome - or even wrong, really - but its execution is the cinematic equivalent of cutting off your nose to prove to your face that spite really exists. De Bankole's neverending quest of indexing, reflexive transaction and nonsensical, perspective-driven secrecy can only exist on the plane of essaydom and Jarmusch, clearly unsure of relevance, gives a late-breaking Bill Murray all the cards to reveal. While it gives us a clear picture of Jarmusch's cynical - and true, and heartbreaking, and unsettling - worldview, it only serves as the summation of miscalculation rather than a moment of clarity.

The Princess and the Frog (John Musker, Ron Clements) C

Continuing their quest to milk every last iota of fable from the mistaken identity of storybook royalty, Musker and Clements turn in their messiest affair yet: A forked tongue attempt to clamp the romantic - and socio-economic - travails of a working class dreamer circa 1920s Big Easy onto a more classical Disney template. The songs fall flat and rote, each more obvious and trite than the last. While a more traditional animation style seems to harken back to the old days, the screenplay has that strangely deceptive complicity that seems to come apart at the quickest of contrived conveniences, backing out of anything remotely heavy by introducing a piece of logic that the younger set will have no trouble accepting and those of us with working brain cells will be unable to ignore. For my money, Corpse Bride takes the awkwardly betrothed among the living and the dead theme to more interesting places both thematically, visually and sonically.

No comments:

Post a Comment