Precious: Based on the Novel Push by Sapphire (Lee Daniels, 2009) C+
First, to address what I've decided to call "The Bouillabase": The idea that this story jams teen pregnancy, incest, welfare fraud, Down's syndrome, illiteracy, AIDS, child abuse and attempted murder into one story, as if aping a steroid-powered American version of one of the Dardenne Bros. pointed social commentaries. There are simply too many elements of decay and devastation to pass as "movie real". But "movie real" rarely applies here, thwarted by cartoonish plodding (the big TV drop, for starters), gooey histrionics (the breakdown in the classroom just before Precious births her second child) and inexplicably twee satire (reminding me that, when I was laundry listing its social elements, I had forgotten to mention that there is also a bickering lesbian couple who, Precious pontificates, "talk like TV channels I don't watch", a sequence eliciting retinal damage from the mountains of rolling your eyes will be forced to climb.) When its not in go-mode, though, Precious does make a deeply felt effort to avoid the sappy happy at close. That final meeting between mama, daughter and social worker cooks with the tense catharsis the rest of the film might be apt to exude, were it not so busy heaping upon the pile every brainstormed misery yet known to man.
The Blind Side (John Lee Hancock, 2009) C
The shot of the railroad tracks it opens with cuts through the BS immediately: This film will speak with the blunt trauma of convention and backrowism. Sandra Bullock is in prime Julia Roberts mode (less treacly, but c'mon) as the rich white lady who helps pave the way for a poor, quiet black kid to become a pro-football player. She enters on a cell phone, the scene an indelible image of exposition, giving her the voice of purpose. Hilariously, almost grotesquely overconfident, she is the good Christian we need to strive to be in order to feel good about ourselves. As a warm, conveniently transformed film based on a true story, "The Blind Side" is easy enough to find cute and minor, partially because Michael himself - the quiet, instinctually protecting gentle giant - is so compelling to watch. His metamorphosis is truly joyful to watch, despite its place among twaddle like, for instance, the youngest son misreading Michael's survival instinct when he asks "What [they] do with all the leftover foods? Seems like they could give it away..." At one point Bullock says "he's changing me" (so the trailer has a place to hook the title), but one wonders why she never before noticed that EVERYONE AROUND HER IS SUDDENLY RACIST. And I don't like that there's a cover of a Nick Drake song over the opening credits, but there's no possible way you could think I was a bigot if I said that. Right? Right?
[It was probably less than brilliant to watch Hancock's film after watching Daniels'. It made 'Precious' seem more dark and sadistic than it really was and 'The Blind Side' more, more, oh no - nevermind - there's no possible way it could be MORE sanitized than this.]
Monday, March 8, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment